World Rugby's new proposals are raising concerns about the potential devaluation of the scrum, which is seen as a unique and integral part of rugby union. A series of law amendments will be voted on in May with the aim of enhancing the sport as a spectacle. These proposals include speeding up the game and encouraging more positive play. However, some controversial ideas have been put forward, such as eliminating the 'Dupont Law' loophole and implementing a global trial of the 20-minute red card.

One particularly contentious proposal is preventing teams from calling for a scrum after winning a free-kick at a scrum, which has sparked criticism from South Africans. The concern is that weaker scrums may exploit this rule to avoid facing a stronger opposition. Critics warn that taking the contest out of scrums could diminish the essence of rugby. Ultimately, World Rugby's plan to alter certain laws has sparked debate among fans and experts, with some questioning the potential impact on the game's traditional elements.